← All guides
5 min readBy Justin Judy

Fractional CFO vs. Software for Contractors

Most trade contractors between $2M and $10M don’t need a fractional CFO first. They need to see their job margins, their cash and their money leaks every week. Software does that now. Bring in a CFO when you are borrowing, buying a competitor, getting ready to sell, or making a call big enough that a person’s judgment pays for itself.

That’s the short version. Here’s how I’d think about it if it were my company.

What a fractional CFO actually does

A fractional CFO is a part-time finance lead. You get a slice of their month on a retainer. For a contractor, the work usually comes down to a handful of things:

  • Reviewing the profit and loss, the cash and the job margins every month
  • Forecasting cash so a slow winter doesn’t sneak up on you
  • Pushing on pricing and bids
  • Sitting in on bank, bonding and buyer conversations
  • Big calls: a new trade, a new market, buying a competitor, selling

All of that is real work, and a good CFO earns their fee on the last two. The catch is the first one. Most of a small contractor’s CFO hours go to the monthly “how are we really doing” review, and that is the part software now does without you paying for a person’s time.

What software can do instead

Long story short, the monthly review is just math on your books. Connect the books and a tool can run that math every week instead of every month:

  • One grade for the whole business, refreshed every week
  • Margin by job type, so a losing line can’t hide inside a blended number
  • Bills paid twice, vendor rates creeping up, vendors you overpay
  • Cash stuck in old invoices
  • Where you stand against other companies in your trade
  • A valuation range, updated as the books change

That’s what we built StashGrade to do for trade contractors. See how it lines up against a CFO’s monthly checklist.

What software won’t do is give you advice or sit across the table from your banker. It tells you what the numbers say. You still decide what to do about them.

Side by side

Fractional CFOContractor softwareBoth
CostA monthly retainerFree to start, then a monthly subscriptionSoftware cuts the CFO hours you pay for
How often it looksMonthly or quarterlyEvery weekEvery week, with a person on the big calls
Knows your tradeDepends who you hireBuilt in, if it’s trade-specificYes
Judgment on big decisionsYesNoYes
Bank and buyer meetingsYesGives them the numbersYes

When to hire a fractional CFO

Hire one when one of these is true:

  • You’re borrowing money or need more bonding capacity
  • You’re buying a competitor or opening a new market
  • You want to sell in the next two or three years
  • Your books are clean, the software is showing you the problems, and you want help deciding what to do about them

If your books are a mess, start with a bookkeeper, not a CFO. Paying CFO rates to fix categories is the most expensive way to get clean books. I don’t want to be the doctor who prescribes before looking, and you shouldn’t hire one either.

The order I’d go in

  • Clean books. A bookkeeper you trust, closing every month.
  • Weekly numbers. Software that reads those books and flags what’s off.
  • A person for the big calls. A CPA or fractional CFO who starts from that read instead of a blank spreadsheet.

Crawl, walk, run. That’s the gist of it.

Common questions

Can software replace a fractional CFO?

It can replace the monthly reporting. It can’t replace judgment on a loan, a purchase or a sale.

Do I need a fractional CFO at $3M in revenue?

Usually not as a first step. Get clean books and weekly numbers first, then bring a CFO in for specific decisions.

Does this replace my bookkeeper?

No. Your bookkeeper keeps the books. Software reads them.

StashGrade reads your QuickBooks and shows what a CFO would check every month: margins, leaks, cash and a grade against your trade. Free to start, read-only. Get your free grade.

StashGrade describes what your books show. This is not financial, investment, tax, accounting or legal advice.

See how your KPIs stack up against a healthy business

Connect QuickBooks and get your margin by job type in minutes. Free to start, read-only.

Connect QuickBooks for free

More for your trade: Fencing, Decking, Roofing, Concrete.